The difference between market intelligence and design intelligence

Elisa del Galdo | 12th May 2016

Clients and non-user experience consultants often ask us, “What is the difference between market research and customer (user) research?” To the uninitiated, the two types of research can look very similar. The process, methodology and skill are usually very aligned. To the market research or user experience expert, however, the objective for each, the resulting data (i.e. market intelligence or design intelligence), and most importantly the insights we seek to gain and how they are used, are very different.

In this article, Head of Customer Experience Elisa del Galdo talks us through how the two types of research differ, and in which situations you would use one over the other.

Market Intelligence: Quantitative data about behaviour

The intelligence we collect from market research usually has a broad focus, collecting data that identifies customer behaviour in a market. It also identifies demographics, categorising customers into a distinct set of segments so we can more effectively sell to them.

Customer research, based on user experience principles, is more in-depth, collecting data on customers’ experiences and the ‘why’; motivations, triggers, drivers, barriers, and pain points that influence their behaviour. Market intelligence effectively identifies the symptoms that indicate there may be an underlying problem driving customers’ reported behaviour and resulting analytics.

Market intelligence data is very valuable to both marketing and user experience consultants. It indicates where there may be opportunities to further investigate behaviour and needs, using user research to gain insight into where a service, tool, app, or piece of content could be created to solve a problem.

Design Intelligence: Understanding the problem

Customer research (sometimes referred to as user experience research) provides the insights that are required to design a solution – design intelligence. This type of research is focused on either:

  1. understanding customers’ experiences in a more general sense to understand overall opportunities more clearly, or
  2. can be directed at a single opportunity identified by research.

Both scenarios have the objective of understanding the underlying problems that customers experience; problems that are driving their behaviour, and degrading their experience. This type of research also generates the kind of information needed for the creation of personas and other design artefacts.

A persona is a vivid representation of a customer that encompasses the description of not just their demographic data, but their behaviours, (and what drives those behaviours), their goals and challenges. Personas are used to represent a multitude of customers and their characteristics, in a limited number, so that they can be more easily used as filters to validate design ideas.

They’re often confused with segments, which are primarily used for marketing purposes. Segments represent a statistically significant grouping of real customers who share some characteristics and their relative size in the market. A segment is used to optimise use of marketing resources to ensure they are deployed where they will have the most impact.

What is the added value of user experience input?

User experience experts dig deeper into understanding the behaviours that customers exhibit; determining motivation, triggers, drivers, barriers, pain points, and their goals, challenges, and context. They add value by understanding the actual problems driving customer behaviour (symptoms) and using that understanding to create a solution.

The questions asked during research interviews are specifically designed to elicit meaningful qualitative information from customers. The knowledge gained from research leads to insights that spark innovation, and the creation of solutions that address actual problems and not just the symptoms that customers display.

Only when we have a clear and deeper understanding of a problem can user experience designers have the knowledge and insight required to design effective solutions that are driven by innovation.

 

Both types of intelligence are essential to the discovery of opportunities and the subsequent further defining of them. They provide an understanding of the customer from both the business and user experience perspective – something that every design in the commercial world must address.

Market intelligence is best placed to drive marketing strategy, which is imperative for the business. Design intelligence is best placed to deliver insights that inform design and foster innovation in the defining of solutions. Together, they make very powerful partners.

 

For more articles about human-centred design, download the second issue of Perspective magazine below.

Introducing_orello_Janssen

Using service design to improve patients’ quality of life

Eimear Power | 29th March 2017

Customer Experience Consultant Eimear Power talks through the process of developing Orello, a service for metastatic prostate cancer patients and their loved ones, in collaboration with Janssen.

read more

target-precision-medicine-healthcare-professional-darts

Precision medicine and the changing role of the healthcare professional

Ditte Funding | 23rd March 2017

The growth of precision medicine introduces a shift away from treating the population as a whole, to treating each patient as an individual. How does this change the role of the healthcare professional (HCP) in the patient journey? Associate Consultant Ditte Funding discusses challenges and opportunities.

read more

Black and white - elderly man - face - Blue Latitude Health

Caring for prostate cancer patients

Frances Peters | 15th March 2017

Although not without its challenges, the appropriate care and support available to patients with prostate cancer is gradually evolving. Associate Consultant Frances Peters takes a look at the issues and concerns facing the caregivers of those with prostate cancer. 

read more